12 December, 2017 - 13 December, 2017
13 January, 2018 - 16 January, 2018
Riva del Garda (Tn), Italy
15 January, 2018 - 18 January, 2018
Sao Paulo, Brazil
23 January, 2018 -
26 January, 2018 - 28 January, 2018
Dennis L. Dalton, Zenith Industrial Chemicals, Singapore. Article first published in ILM May-June 2015 edition. For more information about Zenith Industrial Chemicals please contact the author: firstname.lastname@example.org
The definition of Green Chemistry adopted by the EPA was “Green Chemistry is the design of chemical products and processes that reduce or eliminate the use or generation of hazardous substances. Green chemistry applies across the life cycle of a chemical product, including its design, manufacture, use, and ultimate disposal. Green chemistry is also known as sustainable chemistry”.1
Dennis L. Dalton, Zenith Industrial Chemicals
History of fungicides in leather
Some of the earliest products to be used as fungicides were organo mercury compounds (eg. phenyl mercuric acetate aka PMA) and chlorinated phenols (eg. penta chloro phenol aka PCP). These products were effective in killing fungi but they were also very toxic to other living organisms, including humans.
Newer types of microbicides came into use in the 1950s and 1960s which had relatively lower acute toxicity and a higher degree of specificity. These included phenolics, like para chlorometacresol (PCMC) and ortho phenylphenol (OPP), and 2-(thiocyanomethylthio) benzothiazole (TCMTB). These products were more specific to killing microorganisms at a low dosage. The use of organo mercury compounds and chlorinated phenols eventually became restricted, starting in the 1970s, and TCMTB emerged as the leading fungicide to be used in the leather industry because of its effectiveness, although it suffered drawbacks related to its toxicity and handling hazards.
Figure 1. Zenith operates tropical chambers for the accelerated mould resistance testing of leather. These chambers are automated to maintain ideal conditions of temperature, humidity and air movement to promote rapid mould growth. The chambers typically contain at least 20 different species of fungi actively attacking the leathers under test. Under these extreme conditions, leathers without proper protection fail within the first week of testing.
The need for sustainable fungicides
As more detailed toxicity information was generated for these newer microbicides, it became apparent that some of these might exhibit chronic toxicity, meaning they could cause ill effects as a result of periodic exposure to small amounts over time. In 2006, the EPA classified TCMTB as a possible human carcinogen, based on animal studies2. This triggered similar announcements being made, such as in the Pesticide Action Network (PAN) in the UK, which listed TCMTB in its List of Pesticides that Cause Cancer3.
As a result of this classification, and with all of its leather fungicide products based on TCMTB at the time, Zenith decided to initiate a project to develop newer, safer fungicides for the leather industry to replace its TCMTB products.
The fungicides used in the leather industry have traditionally been “industrial microbicide concentrates”, having high active levels of 30%, 50% and even 100%. These products were meant for use in multiple industries. The leading fungicides used in leather in the U.S are EPA-registered for use in over 30 different industrial applications besides leather, such as adhesives, cooling tower water, metal working fluids, pulp and paper mills, oil recovery drilling mud, sewage effluent water, wallpaper, and wood.
Figure 2. View of leather samples exposed in the tropical chamber.
As they are concentrated industrial chemicals, these fungicide concentrates exhibit high acute toxicity and hazardous handling characteristics, similar to concentrated acids and alkalis. They are therefore classified as “Hazardous Substances”, also known as “Dangerous Goods” (DG).
Because they are meant for use in many different industries, this “one-size-fits-all” product approach has the disadvantage that one product cannot perform optimally in all types of systems and environments. The products also work in leather, but a large proportion of the fungicide is often not taken up by the leather and is lost to the effluent. This means that hazardous waste is generated in the leather making process.
Zenith’s approach to developing new fungicides broke with past practices by setting the objective of creating fungicidal products designed specifically and exclusively for use in leather. Such tailor-made products would be far more efficient for use in leather than one-size-fits-all industrial concentrates. This would allow for lower usage levels of fungicide as well as lower active content in the fungicide formulation. This in turn would produce a less concentrated product with lower toxicity and safer handling characteristics. In essence, this was a very simple and logical approach but at the same time it was ground-breaking since it had never been done before.
The basic requirements for such a product were that it should perform with maximum efficiency in leather (with drastically reduced waste in the effluent), requiring lowest possible dosage levels and active ingredient levels, and secondly that the fungicidal active have a “clean” toxicity profile.
Figure 3. Wet-blue leather samples after four weeks’ exposure in the tropical chamber. The sample on the left passed with a mould growth rating of “0” (no growth). The sample in the middle failed with a mould growth rating of “65”. The sample on the right failed with a mould growth rating of “90”. Samples are rated on a scale from “0” (no mould) to “100” (completely covered with mould).
New fungicide development project
The first critical stage in Zenith’s development project was to create a “carrier” system designed to effectively disperse in tanning systems with good stability in high electrolyte solutions. This carrier would be the vehicle to deliver the fungicide active into the leather to achieve maximum possible uptake with minimum residuals remaining in the tanning liquors. Furthermore, this carrier was to be made without the use of components that are unfriendly to people or the environment, such as organic solvents.
Following extensive formulation development work and performance testing, a carrier system was developed which proved very effective and consistent in performance.
The second stage was to identify a suitable active substance with fungicidal efficacy profile covering all fungal species that attack leather. The active was also required to have a clean toxicity profile. Finally, the active was to possess appropriate physical characteristics allowing it to be formulated into the carrier.
A number of suitable actives were identified as meeting all the requirements. Several formulations were found to be very effective using very low active levels ranging from around 4-9%. One of these new products, designated Zenith 399, is based on the fungicidal active octhilinone, which is an alkylthiazole with a broad fungicidal spectrum of activity, excellent toxicity profile and is compatible in the carrier formulation. This product was selected for more in-depth testing.
Figure 4. Finished leather samples after four weeks’ exposure in the tropical chamber. The sample on the left passed with a mould growth rating of “0” (no growth). The sample in the middle failed with a mould growth rating of “85”. The sample on the right failed with a mould growth rating of “95”. Samples are rated on a scale from “0” (no mould) to “100” (completely covered with mould).
Performance data were developed by application of the product under full-scale tannery conditions at numerous tanneries. The product was applied under identical conditions to the commercial fungicide in use at the tannery and at the same use level or at equal cost. Cuttings taken from the production runs treated with the new fungicide and with the commercial fungicide in use were evaluated for their mould resistance using the industry standard “tropical chamber” test. This is an accelerated test based on the ASTM Standard Test Method D7584 (American Society for Testing and Materials).
Zenith operates automated tropical chambers that are maintained at a temperature of approximately 30˚C and a relative humidity level of 95-98%. See Figures 1 and 2. The Zenith chambers typically contain at least 20 different species of fungi actively attacking the leathers under test. Without proper protection, leathers fail within the first week of testing. Samples are rated weekly for mould growth on a scale from 0 to 100 (with 0 being no mould and 100 being fully covered with mould). Leathers must pass four weeks in the tropical chamber to possess long-term mould resistance. See examples of tested leathers in Figures 3 and 4.
Extensive testing performed on thousands of leathers consistently showed the new Zenith fungicide to outperform the TCMTB standard in terms of providing longer protection, with lower use levels, and lower treatment cost. Figures 5 and 6 show performance comparisons with TCMTB and a competitive fungicide containing the same fungicidal active as the Zenith product and at the same active content.
Figure 5. Comparison of the effectiveness of 0.1% Zenith fungicide (9% active content) with 0.1% TCMTB fungicide (30% active content) in wet-blue leather.
Chrome tanned leathers treated with 0.1% Zenith Fungicide (9% active content) and with 0.1% TCMTB Fungicide (30% active content) were exposed in the tropical chamber for the standard four-week period. After four weeks the wet-blues treated with Zenith and TCMTB both remained mould-free. Therefore, the test was continued beyond four weeks until differences in performance would become apparent. The TCMTB treated leather remained mould-free for nine weeks and started moulding in week 10. The Zenith treated leather remained mould-free for 15 weeks and only started showing mould growth in week 16. In the tropical chamber test, one week is equivalent to at least one month in the “real world” under harshest conditions. Therefore the TCMTB leathers would be mould-resistant for nine months and the Zenith leathers would be mould-resistant for 15 months. This means that six months longer protection would be achieved with Zenith. Alternatively, the dosage of the Zenith fungicide could be reduced if such long protection is not needed, resulting in even lower treatment costs.
New generation green fungicide technology
This development initiative produced new “green” fungicide technology specifically for use only in leather manufacture. The product formulations are designed to achieve optimum uptake in leather: nearly all of the fungicide is taken up with little or no waste.
Designing products to prevent waste is a key principle of green chemistry. The older generation fungicides, which were not designed for use in leather, allow a proportion of the fungicide added into the process to wind up in the spent liquor going to the effluent.
Since the new products are preferentially taken up by the leather rather than remaining in the liquor, they are highly efficient in use and lower dosage levels can be used to achieve protection. The new fungicide formulations contain active levels in the 4-9% range. Even at such low active content levels, these products can be used at dosage levels that are 20% lower than the TCMTB standard and provide equal or better fungal protection. This has been proven by direct comparative trials conducted in co-operation with hundreds of customers, as well as independent studies4.
The new Zenith technology has much lower acute toxicity and is far less aggressive to the skin compared to other fungicides. Dermal irritation studies show the new technology fungicide products to be completely non-corrosive and non-irritating to the skin. Therefore the products have been widely adopted for use in skin contact applications with over 300 tanneries using them in retanning and finished leather applications such as furniture and automotive upholstery and footwear. This has opened up new opportunities for companies to produce finished products such as shoes that are resistant to mould growth.
The products are essentially odourless, making them very user-friendly for tannery staff compared to other fungicides that have strong irritating odours. Low odour is also a desirable benefit for automotive use.
Overall, the new Zenith products have lower toxicity and are much safer to handle. Therefore, they are the only leather fungicides not classified as “Hazardous Substances”. Not being a hazardous substance represents a significant breakthrough in the area of fungicide products and makes the new Zenith range of fungicides stand out as the “green” leather fungicides. This technology is also approved by EPA for spray application onto wet-blue, thanks to its safer handling properties.
These products also exhibit lower aquatic toxicity and very little of the fungicide goes to the effluent because of more efficient uptake by the leather. Furthermore, these unique formulations use a non-toxic, non-polluting liquid carrier system, which is far more environment-friendly than the organic solvents used in traditional solvent-based fungicides, which release solvents into the atmosphere and the wastewater.
Figure 6. Comparison of the effectiveness of 0.1% Zenith fungicide (9% active content) with 0.35% Fungicide T (9% active content) in wet-blue leather.
Chrome tanned leathers treated with 0.1% Zenith fungicide (9% active content) were compared to chrome tanned leathers treated with 0.35% Fungicide T (9% active content), a competitive fungicide containing the same active ingredient as Zenith. The Fungicide T leathers remained mould-free for only two weeks. The Zenith leathers remained mould-free for 15 weeks. Although both products contain the same active ingredient and at the same active content, the competitive product Fungicide T at the much higher dosage level of 0.35% provided protection for only two weeks, while the Zenith product at a dosage of only 0.1% provided protection for 15 weeks. This study illustrates the importance of the Zenith proprietary formulation technology, which is specifically designed for use in leather.
Zenith has successfully developed and introduced a series of new green fungicides for the leather industry. These products are different from any other fungicides in performance and physical characteristics. Unlike any other fungicide, the products are water-clear liquids that have no odour.
The first of these products to be introduced has been in commercial use for more than five years. Over 400 tanneries in more than 10 countries are now using the products. All of Zenith’s TCMTB business has been replaced by this new green technology.
The types of leather being protected include wet-blue, wet-white, vegetable tan, retanned and finished leather. Articles produced include furniture and automotive upholstery, footwear, garments and more.
These new products meet the definition and key principles of Green Chemistry:
• Design chemical products and processes that reduce or eliminate the use or generation of hazardous substances.
• Design chemicals to prevent waste.
• Design chemicals that are fully effective with minimum toxicity.
• Design chemicals without solvents or with safer solvents.
• Design chemicals that do not persist in environment.
Zenith green leather fungicides provide a safe, green and effective alternative to other fungicides, demonstrating that green chemistry does not require making compromises in performance or cost.
1. US EPA Green Chemistry Program http://www.epa.gov/gcc/pubs/basic_info.html 2. 2-(Thiocyanomethylthio) benzothiazole – US National Library of Medicine - Toxnet – Hazardous Substances Data Base – HSDB Number: 6450 – Last Review Date: 1/15/2015 3. Pesticide Action Network (PAN) UK – The List of Lists – Pesticides which cause cancer 4. Allsop, T.; Evaluation of Fungicide, LASRA Annual Conference, October 2009.