Mike Redwood

Columnist

International Leather Maker


I have often observed tanners dropping marketing into a communications slot and ignoring the vital area of marketing strategy. Business strategy carried out without the bigger picture provided by marketing tools fails.

In moments of volatility, such as now, strategy minded tanners worrying about the role of place in leathermaking will likely have read Hoover’s Location Theory and the Shoe and Leather Industries (1937). It is classed as the seminal work on the subject.

The U.S. is a good case study. When New York grew quickly in the 1600s, butchers were allowed to deposit their hides in an area between the Brooklyn Bridge and Wall Street and with water available in this area, it became known as the ‘Swamp’; it was a natural place for tanners to start operations. When the population expanded, the tanners moved out of the city to the Catskills forests from where their hemlock bark had previously been shipped. Later with the railroads, refrigeration and the advancing skill of tan extraction from bark abattoirs, tanners began to have a greater choice of location.

Hoover’s wider New England study demonstrates this process almost perfectly. Water transport and access to hides and markets originally favoured the region, but these advantages became transitory and eventually its location relative to expanding western markets became disadvantageous. Nevertheless, the accumulated pool of skilled footwear labour continued to hold production there until recent decades.

Leather districts live on

Leather provides an unusually clear example of the initial natural or market advantage being superseded by created localisation advantage: an industry first comes for water, hides, tanning materials, labour or, as in Sialkot (Pakistan), military demand, but can survive beyond these because it has created skills, suppliers, institutions, reputation and dense commercial relationships that are harder to move than raw materials.

As with the Swamp, Bermondsey in London developed a major concentration of tanners after butchers were instructed to leave their hides there. This location had its own river feeding into the Thames and sat on the edge of the Southern oak forests. Over time it developed specialised labour and suppliers and the associated knowledge accumulation to build community longevity. The subsequent creation of institutions supported a self-reinforcing localisation.

Leather has some specific elements that make this process particularly relevant, the first being the complexity of the raw material. Hides and skins are far from uniform so experienced judgement remains valuable. Areas like touch, colour, handle, cutting yield and process correction are learned through practice and are an essential element that becomes part of a community’s tacit knowledge. Over time, specialist suppliers for chemicals, machinery, testing, maintenance and components for leather goods or footwear manufacture become established as it becomes clear local demand is large enough to support it. As a cluster becomes larger, shared water and waste management can be established to handle wastewater treatment, chrome recovery and sludge management.

As can be seen in Italy with third party processing and in Pakistan with finishing, different operations can be distributed to specialist firms offering great flexibility and opportunities for innovation. I have watched this with splitting, shaving, printing and wider finishing.

Reputation should be treasured

Such a cluster over time builds a strong reputation which pulls buyers looking for these multiple capabilities and new ideas. There are many studies of clusters and networks that show how clusters go beyond the natural assets that caused their creation to “produced assets” through shared infrastructure, dedicated services, specialist labour, knowledge spillover and lower inter-firm transaction costs. Some of the studies of clusters, many of which have included leather and footwear areas such as Brazil’s Sinos Valley Cluster centred around Novo Hamburgo, identify three stages for this evolution.

  1. “Resource-oriented location”: Tanning follows hides, bark, water, salt, labour or military demand.
  2. “Capability-oriented localisation”: Firms remain because skills, suppliers, subcontractors and market knowledge has accumulated.
  3. “Institutional anchoring”: Associations, laboratories, schools, fairs, environmental systems, brands and collective identity make the district reproducible.

Mixing this thrift with both Hoover and what we are seeing today, a more rigorous approach suggests a leather cluster has several layers. The first would relate to these actual geographical aspects of where the hides, skins, tanning materials and other inputs are. The second then becomes how expensive is it to move them and with it, the third as seen in the New York Swamp, where tanning/manufacturing can most efficiently occur. The fourth and fifth layers start as specialised skills arrive or develop as do machinery, chemicals, components and related manufacturers.

Allied to this is an essential layering of customers, agents, distributors, merchants, brands and exporters. The wider North Shore of Boston is interesting here as Peabody became the major tanning centre, but it was in reality a leather footwear industrial system. In this, Peabody was about leather, Lynn was women’s footwear, Haverhill slippers and low-cut footwear, Beverly shoe machinery, and Salem/Boston was all about ports, trade and finance with its own “leather district”.

The seventh and eighth layers here are most important for future advancement on a strong foundation and those involve supporting and maintaining the accumulated tacit knowledge embodied in people and institutions and with it, what elements provide the identity and reputation that makes a “Made in Santa Croce” in Italy or “Made in Himeji” in Japan valuable.

The place itself becomes part of the product’s value proposition. So let us be clear that a leather cluster is not created by putting tanneries together. It emerges when material, technical, human, commercial and institutional relationships become geographically embedded.

Tuscan cluster

Consequently, the knowledge of making leather and working with it becomes part of the place. To keep this accumulated intelligence alive and growing, it must be supported by strong institutions that guard its past, provide training for the future and links to new ideas and thinking. The Genuine Italian Vegetable-Tanned Leather Consortium in Tuscany, founded in 1994, is typical of a body that demonstrates how the competitive advantage of a leather district can be maintained. This is achieved by not only making great product but building on and using knowledge gained over decades and even centuries.

It is also an opportunity for certain types of clusters to accelerate their use of wastes and byproducts. Anaerobic digestion to produce biogas for power and gelatine are two examples where scale matters, so having a cluster opens up more options for circularity and wider community benefit.

Ignorance and thoughtlessness have killed off many great business communities by giving no credence to the knowledge held in the people and the institutions. Perhaps today, as efficiency and cost so often overwhelm any conception of value over time, it is even worse. It is what we in Britain saw recently in the famous saddle making town of Walsall, where only a determined move by designer and educator Lauren Broxton looks likely to have saved its leather museum. Her crowdfunded project for the industrial building next door to expand a leather educational facility, establish her studio and provide space for others, is exactly the sort of organisation we must all support. Without continual renewal the old gets misunderstood, ignored and forgotten.


mike@internationalleathermaker.com

You can find Dr Mike Redwood across social media at @michaelredwood.

Publication and Copyright of “Redwood Column” remains with the publishers of International Leather Maker. The articles cannot be reproduced in any way without the express permission of the publisher. The views are those of the author and not necessarily those of ILM.