Mike Redwood

Columnist

International Leather Maker


We use Brundtland’s familiar formulation to define “sustainable development”, Stahel for circularity, Paracelsus for toxicology, Duffus for heavy-metals, EU Regulations to guide us through biodegradability and ILM’s Technical Editor Karl Flowers to guide us through claims about being “natural”. All these are potential “weasel” words that need clarity in the definition.

But how should we define the latest weasel term: resilience. It is now applied to regenerative farming, military doctrine and defence planning, as well as children’s education and wellbeing, plus finance, supply chains, urban planning and psychology. Like “sustainability” in the 1990s, it has spread so far that it risks meaning everything and therefore nothing. On LinkedIn, resilience increasingly appears as a compulsory virtue rather than a defined capability.

In the tanneries where I worked, we protected ourselves against external shocks by holding some spare capacity and staff trained in multiple skills. And working only one shift in the day meant that maximum output would be decided by drum capacity, and this could for a while at least be balanced by holding work in progress. It helped me a lot in El Salvador during their civil war, along with improvising with more natural materials for processing when imported chemicals were missing.

Redundancy was eliminated by efficiency

This came to be classed as “redundancy” and soon was considered wasteful by those seeking efficiency. Over time, much of that spare capacity came to be treated as unnecessary cost and stocks, work in progress, machinery and some staff were eliminated. Nowadays redundancy and duplication of this sort is one part of resilience, but only a small part.

While a little of what we now call resilience is the rediscovery of the spare capacity, a multi-skilled workforce and financial prudence that good industrial management once regarded as essential, what truly matters for resilience is a systematic understanding of which reserves and alternatives matter most.

Defining resilience for the tannery

To follow the same pattern I have used for the other definitions, where I try anchoring each concept to a canonical source, there is actually an authoritative definition to cite. For resilience, this is ISO 22316:2017.

ISO 22316:2017 defines organisational resilience as the “ability of an organisation to absorb and adapt in a changing environment.” In terms of tannery management, what is required is organisational resilience.

The new resilience frameworks ask organisations to identify critical services, prepare for disruption, respond and adapt, then recover and learn. This means looking far beyond the machine fire that might knock a buffing machine out, to the much greater problems now becoming more frequent such as floods, droughts or power failures that impact the whole plant.

Occasionally, C.S. Holling’s Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems (1973) is put forward as providing the intellectual foundation of this concept. In truth, Holling helps explain an important distinction behind it, rather than supplying the most suitable business definition.

He did so by distinguishing two properties that are easily confused:

  1. Stability: The ability of a system to return to equilibrium after a temporary disturbance—particularly how quickly and with how little fluctuation. This can sometimes be called the bounce back.
  2. Resilience: The ability to absorb change and disturbance while preserving the relationships that allow the system to persist.

This takes us to the view that appearing steady under ordinary conditions is not sufficient evidence of an ability to survive substantial disturbance. Holling effectively challenged the assumption that stability around an equilibrium was the best way to understand ecological persistence.

Transformation matters, more now

Folke and colleagues developed this discussion in 2010 by distinguishing resilience, adaptability and transformability: remaining within critical thresholds, adjusting along an existing development path and creating a fundamentally different path when necessary. A transformation at one level may support resilience at another: an individual tannery might change its products or processes so that the business, employment or a wider leathermaking cluster can endure. Such changes look increasingly likely in the future of leather.

When looking at transformation and what separates resilience from sustainability, consider that while sustainability asks you to stay somewhere, resilience permits, even demands, that you move somewhere. The distinction is not that sustainability means standing still while resilience means changing. Rather, sustainability asks whether an activity can meet present needs without compromising those of future generations. Alternatively, resilience asks how it copes with disturbance and changing conditions. Sometimes achieving either requires transformation.

This was proven during the Covid pandemic, when many tanners had to completely change to survive. Finding direct routes to customers, jumping to new segments that were still doing business, helping hide dealers with rendering unusable hides. Most tanners reverted afterwards while some retained parts of the new areas. All learned a great deal.

What are we trying to preserve?

The problem with loose definition and usage is that resilience can easily offer reassurance while leaving two unanswered questions: “What exactly are we trying to preserve?” and “Why is preserving it desirable?” The criticism is not that resilience is meaningless, but that it becomes slippery when writers leave those questions unanswered.

If we view resilience as the capacity of a system to absorb disturbance, adapt and – where necessary – transform, while retaining its core function and identity, then the boundary of “core function and identity” must be defined within the context, as with Paracelsus.

That last clause is the honest part. With any toxic/heavy-metal definitions, the term is only operational once it is clear about context. Resilience of what, to what, for whom and judged by whom – because a resilient thing is not the same as a resilient system, and a system resilient for one stakeholder can be rigid and harmful for another. Leave out the clarity of the four questions and the word is spin, another weasel word.

Ecological resilience measures how much disturbance a system can absorb before flipping into a different regime – and it does not assume the old state was the one worth keeping. So, a “bounce back” approach to defining resilience might work for a supply chain after a port strike but is incoherent when applied to a farm after drought or a child after a traumatic shock. Sometimes, the system that existed before the shock should not be restored at all, and “bouncing back” to it is the failure mode, not the success. Perhaps that is why after Covid we wrote about “Build back better?” It certainly enjoyed political usage by both Prime Minister Boris Johnson and President Joe Biden. Sadly, for them both, this slogan contains two weasel words and only one concrete one (“build”). It promises direction (“better”) without ever specifying for whom, by what measure, or compared to which baseline.

After a flood, we still need to ask how quickly normal production can resume. But we must also ask how much-repeated flooding, drought and supply chain disruption the tannery can withstand before its present way of operating becomes unviable, and what we intend to preserve when that point arrives.

With British citizens having recently been told to stock up in case of weather events, infrastructure failure or war, all of which are now expected, these questions have more relevance in current times. Through history, tanneries have been important in wars. Just ask what will yours need to do in the next?

 


mike@internationalleathermaker.com

You can find Dr Mike Redwood across social media at @michaelredwood.

Publication and Copyright of “Redwood Column” remains with the publishers of International Leather Maker. The articles cannot be reproduced in any way without the express permission of the publisher. The views are those of the author and not necessarily those of ILM.