
Mike Redwood
Columnist
International Leather Maker
It was a surprise, back in 2013, to listen to a BBC radio programme on food and find a whole 30 minutes of Sir Paul McCartney explaining why he and his family had turned vegetarian. Some 50 years ago, he bought a remote sheep farm on the northern end of the Mull of Kintyre – a wild area in western Scotland. He explained that while looking at the sheep out of the window, they had decided they were too nice to eat.
In the programme, he then went on to explain that some years later, in 2006, the FAO produced a report entitled Livestock’s Long Shadow which McCartney argued gave their beliefs scientific credibility. Although attacked for its bias and asymmetry in comparative analysis, with a sizeable 2013 correction, this study has had a big impact.
It was in October 2001 that his daughter Stella had launched her own luxury brand at the Paris Fashion Week announcing that she would never use leather and fur. By 2006 and 2007, she was roundly attacking leather in speeches and videos mixing carefully selected data, with complaints about the use of chemicals not used for decades, even centuries, and became a lightning rod for all the ills of the leather industry.
We should remember this was the moment the leather industry was reminding itself that it should not waste money promoting leather since “like a fine wine all the hides and skins available are tanned and sold”, so advertising would only upset the price structure.
Many hopeful new materials have come to nothing
Today, vegetarian and vegan approaches have not made the headway feared and the issues leather faces are far more complex. While still not liked by leather makers, the dedication Stella McCartney has shown to her task and her support for new materials has certainly won respect. The outcomes have required continual adaptation. At very considerable expense, she searches the world, and more often than not personally visits, plants producing what appear to be world changing biomaterials only to find two or three years later they come to nought.
Faux leather bags targeting a luxury segment are by definition overpriced, so many McCartney buyers, attracted by the name, make a purchase in the belief they will find the same quality and durability only to find a bag which simply does not match the price point.
However powerful the animal-free ethics of the brand, it cannot overcome the huge disparity between luxury pricing and plastic-based materials. On platforms such as Reddit, we read about rapid deterioration, loss of shape and aging that emphasises decline rather than the maturing that comes with leather’s evolving patina.
The battleground of US$1000 plus handbags is the wrong arena
There is a coherence in McCartney’s choice of animal avoidance with lower impact and circularity, but this carries two problems. Most important, putting the ethics aside, the environmental impact and circularity does not stack up, and so a battleground of US$1,000 plus handbags is probably the wrong arena.
At this autumn’s shows, McCartney made a move to partially remove wool by testing a Japanese Brewed Protein in blends instead. As with the bags, the one area of this project that seems untested is the comparative wear of equivalent finished garments over years of service—covering a range of aspects such as fibre blend, processing, care, repair, shedding, reuse and end-of-life. To properly fill a luxury space, the Brewed Protein will battle not only with average cashmere and merino, but also with regenerative wool, recycled wool, virgin polyester and recycled polyester. The Japanese Spiber fibre seems in reality to be a manufactured recombinant protein polymer, molecularly designed and biosynthesised in fermentation vessels: a long way from shearing a sheep for a wool fibre.
Emotional videos and a lack of scientific rigour is a risky underpinning in a luxury market whose survival totally relies on superior and unfailing levels of integrity. Just trying hard and sincerely hoping to get it right is not enough. In fact, the Spiber wool alternate from Japan sounds like a good material and an interesting environmental approach would be to see how it could be developed not to replace natural wool but synthetic fibres based on fossil fuels. The same with her faux leathers, which would be much better suited to battle the fossil fuel materials than battling with leather. There are better ways for humans who do not want to be involved in animal materials than wasting billions on inadequate faux leathers.
I was also struck in recent interviews while complaining about animal mistreatment in the wider industry. In a long quote in one well respected newspaper, she said: “At the end of the day it’s about how kind you are, but monitoring that kindness requires real work. At Stella, we police everything from start to finish at my cost, at my time. If I use wool, I can show you exactly where it’s coming from, and I’m proud of that. But I’m alone in that, and I shouldn’t be.”
Having had the opportunity to spend some time staying on a Merino farm in New Zealand owned by the Rowley Farm, I’m not convinced about all her views on cruelty in the wool industry, but I defend her right to say it and act on it. But if you want to lead the pack, that investment in ensuring your own materials are correct is an essential part of doing business. In leather, we make many statements, but in places around the world where tanning industry bodies talk leather up that they are not willing to implement or enforce proper rules of industrial behaviour. That means how people, materials, water and waste are managed. Brands do not invest enough, governments are either lazy or obfuscating with enforcement, the International Council of Tanners has not moved a single recalcitrant nation from bad to good behaviour. So, in that regard, I see we all need to tell Stella McCartney to keep pushing for inspection and doing the right thing, and then do it ourselves.
Looking at sources like Ecolife, she, and others copying her route in fashion, have a clear overall pattern, with quite a strong hierarchy. The order of priorities is as follows:
1. Avoid animal-derived materials where possible.
2. Develop lower-impact alternatives.
3. Reduce virgin fossil inputs and improve circularity.
4. Preserve luxury appearance and acceptable technical performance.
If as a tanner, you spend time looking at materials, this creates problems. With wool, even if other livestock elements like leather are shunned, a clever natural material is placed as environmentally worse than a synthetic; as has been the plan for fur.
It essentially ignores important lifecycle areas such as durability, longevity, repairability, moisture management, thermal regulation, biodegradability and established end-of-life and recovery routes. Throughout, the natural is overlooked while chemical processing is preferred. So, while Spiber is scientifically significant and potentially valuable, that position is reached only when performance, durability and fibre-to-fibre metabolic recycling are fully explained.
Nevertheless, in many eras other than the non-negotiable animal-free principle, the leather trade would support the McCartney approach; it does seem that the animal-free approach puts heavy constraints on targets for durability, circularity and excluding fossil fuels. This tension at the core inevitably creates uneven results which go some way to explaining the higher-than-expected negative consumer comments. While the leather industry battles with itself over communications, there is a bigger one here when calling a material “plant-based” or “plastic-free”. This hides the fact that the polymer is made with fermentation energy, process chemicals, solvents, agricultural feedstock and additional synthetic fibres or finishes in the final article.
The leather industry can learn from this hierarchy, but only if it uses it to do better.
mike@internationalleathermaker.com
You can find Dr Mike Redwood across social media at @michaelredwood.
Publication and Copyright of “Redwood Column” remains with the publishers of International Leather Maker. The articles cannot be reproduced in any way without the express permission of the publisher. The views are those of the author and not necessarily those of ILM.



